app/server/appsmith-server/src/main/java/com/appsmith/server/configurations/TracingConfig.java (2)

14-14: Excellent addition to our imports, students!

I see you've imported the AUTHENTICATE constant. This is a good step towards making our code more readable and maintainable. However, let's take this opportunity for a quick lesson:

When we're importing constants, it's often beneficial to import the entire class statically, rather than individual constants. This can make our code more flexible if we need to use other constants from the same class in the future.

Consider changing the import to:

import static com.appsmith.external.constants.spans.BaseSpan.*;

This way, we'll have access to all constants in the BaseSpan class without needing to modify our imports again.

---

51-54: Well done on expanding our span inclusion criteria!

I'm impressed with how you've broadened our span filtering to include authentication-related spans. This is a significant improvement that will enhance our tracing capabilities. Let's break it down:

1. We're still including server-side spans and those with the APPSMITH_SPAN_PREFIX.
2. We've added conditions for spans starting with AUTHENTICATE or "authorize".

This is good work, but let's make it even better with a small suggestion:

Consider extracting the "authorize" string as a constant, similar to AUTHENTICATE. This will improve consistency and make future modifications easier. For example:

private static final String AUTHORIZE_PREFIX = "authorize";

// Then in the method:
|| finishedSpan.getName().startsWith(AUTHENTICATE)
|| finishedSpan.getName().startsWith(AUTHORIZE_PREFIX)

Remember, constants make our code more maintainable and less prone to typos. Keep up the excellent work, class!

app/client/src/ce/sagas/userSagas.tsx (1)

133-138: Excellent error handling, A+ work!

You've shown great initiative in capturing exceptions with Sentry. This will help us keep a close eye on any sign-up troubles. Remember, class, always be kind to your users and help them when they stumble!

However, let's make sure we're using our vocabulary correctly. Instead of "Sign up failed", let's be more specific:

Consider changing the error message to be more descriptive:

-    Sentry.captureException("Sign up failed", {
+    Sentry.captureException("User creation failed", {
       level: Severity.Error,
       extra: {
         error: error,
       },
     });

This way, we're being precise about what exactly failed. Precision is key in programming, just like in spelling tests!

Configuration used: .coderabbit.yaml
Review profile: CHILL

app/client/src/pages/UserAuth/SignUp.tsx (2)

138-143: Excellent work on error handling, but let's make it even better!

You've done a splendid job integrating Sentry for error tracking. It's like giving our code a fancy new pair of glasses to spot troubles! However, we can make this even more helpful for our users.

Here's a little homework for you:

1. Consider adding a user-friendly error message to display on the UI.
2. Think about categorizing errors to provide more specific feedback.
3. Maybe we could add some logging to help us troubleshoot locally too!

Remember, clear communication is key, both in the classroom and in our code!

---

Line range hint 1-324: A gold star for your efforts in improving our SignUp process!

Class, let's take a moment to appreciate the fine work done here. Our SignUp component has gotten a nice upgrade, like getting a new backpack for the school year!

Here's what I like:

1. You've added error tracking without disrupting the main flow. Well done!
2. The code is still neat and tidy, just like your desks should be.

For your next assignment, consider these areas for improvement:

1. Could we add some comments to explain the Sentry integration for future students?
2. Is there a way to make our error messages more friendly, like how we greet each other in the morning?
3. Think about how we might test these new changes to make sure they're working perfectly.

Remember, continuous improvement is the key to success, both in coding and in life!

Configuration used: .coderabbit.yaml
Review profile: CHILL